"Brutality Wrapped in Peanut Butter"

This article by Arundhati Roy in the Guardian has lots to say, cogently, about the war. (Although I don't know what that thing with the gecko is all about.) She touches on many issues; here's what she says about our bomb-and-food drops:

Aid workers have condemned it as a cynical, dangerous, public-relations exercise. They say that air-dropping food packets is worse than futile.

First, because the food will never get to those who really need it. More dangerously, those who run out to retrieve the packets risk being blown up by landmines. A tragic alms race.

Nevertheless, the food packets had a photo-op all to themselves. Their contents were listed in major newspapers. They were vegetarian, we're told, as per Muslim dietary law (!) Each yellow packet, decorated with the American flag, contained: rice, peanut butter, bean salad, strawberry jam, crackers, raisins, flat bread, an apple fruit bar, seasoning, matches, a set of plastic cutlery, a serviette and illustrated user instructions.

After three years of unremitting drought, an air-dropped airline meal in Jalalabad! The level of cultural ineptitude, the failure to understand what months of relentless hunger and grinding poverty really mean, the US governmentıs attempt to use even this abject misery to boost its self-image, beggars description.

Reverse the scenario for a moment. Imagine if the Taliban government was to bomb New York City, saying all the while that its real target was the US government and its policies. And suppose, during breaks between the bombing, the Taliban dropped a few thousand packets containing nan and kebabs impaled on an Afghan flag. Would the good people of New York ever find it in themselves to forgive the Afghan government? Even if they were hungry, even if they needed the food, even if they ate it, how would they ever forget the insult, the condescension? Rudi Guiliani, Mayor of New York City, returned a gift of $10m from a Saudi prince because it came with a few words of friendly advice about American policy in the Middle East. Is pride a luxury that only the rich are entitled to?



M E-L posted this on October 26, 2001
It is filed under International Affairs

It is also indexed with the following tags: Arundhati Roy | Afghanistan | War | PBJ | Food |

Comments
Post a comment









Remember personal info?




Enter the following security code to prove that you are human:





Note: HTML is allowed in your comment. Please be patient as posting can take up to a minute depending on traffic. If you're planning on spamming, don't bother; URLs in comments will not be indexed by any search engine.


















Ishbadiddle buttonTriptronix buttonMovable Type buttonMT Plugins buttonCreative Commons buttonCSS Tableless buttonEdit Pad buttonMax Design buttonLogin buttonEmail button

1m blogsageless buttonNYC Blogger buttonGeoURL buttonBlogdex buttonBlogShares buttonBlogstreet buttonEatonweb buttonTechnorati button

DonorsChoose buttonFlying Spaghetti MonsterGet Firefox!Stand up for your rightsWin With Blingo!

Ishbadiddle Full Posts Feed ButtonIshbadiddle Posts Excerpts Feed ButtonBloglines subscribe buttonIshbadiddle LiveJournal Feed Button