September's Here Again

engraving of man in gas mask

There's this haunting little song, "September," that opens David Sylvian's Secrets of the Beehive. In less than a minute and a half, it sets the tone for this album of melancholy and beautiful songs. I don't remember buying the LP, but I played it a lot in college, when I had a hunger for melancholy and beauty. The vinyl has been untouched for years now. I put it on the turntable again last night, and listened.

"September's here again..."

Yesterday I watched a plane fly over my head. Coming out of JFK, still low enough for me to see its size, its heft, a huge metal machine. "It looks like a missile with wings," I thought. And then: "Oh, damn." Because I thought that was all over with. Being anxious about low-flying planes. Or when the subway stops between stations.

"... September's here, again."

But now the calendar has come around. And I find myself reacting more viscerally to news about September 11th. For the past year, we've been writing and arguing about war, politics, civil rights, greed, and propaganda. Not so much about fear. Or death. It's still there, though, long after the ashes washed out of our clothes. I wish it weren't. I wish I didn't keep thinking about what happened that day. I wish that I didn't need to carry a breathing mask in my bag to feel safer. I wish I didn't feel guilty, because I didn't lose anyone, because so many others went through so much that was worse.

Of course, most of all, I wish they were back. The towers. The 3,000 people. The normal world.

Most of the country lived September 11th 2001 through television -- hell, even with only one station available, we spent most of our time watching the news too. But I refuse to watch on 9/11/02. Whatever they're showing will probably make me angry (like that Super Bowl tribute). Case in point: singing our National Anthem on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial will be Kelly Clarkson, the winner of Fox's "American Idol". There's not really much more to say, is there?

I'll be spending this September 11th with my family, and my friends, and my community. There's a candlelight vigil in Prospect Park. See you there?


M E-L posted this on September 06, 2002
It is filed under Community, Featured Posts, Local News, Sounds

It is also indexed with the following tags: 9/11 | Memorials | PTSD | New York City | Kelly Clarkson | American Idol | David Sylvian |

Comments
Colin wrote:

My strategy for dealing with September 11th was to focus on small, inconsequential details preferrably as far away from the "events" as possible. It's a scale with fireballs on one side and, say, "too much salt in this oatmeal" on the other. But of course, the scale is tipped, so things slide toward the fireball side, but I cling desperately, seeking purchase among the minutia. It didn't work for me then, and it won't work for me now.... BUT, here's my comment about your genuinely touching (and much appreciated) post, Mike:

Don't Blame Kelly Clarkson. Here's my point....

Comment #1 :: link :: September 7, 2002 09:00 AM
Colin wrote:

While I'm just about the last person to defend the Fox network (and I'm not*), this is kind of a case in which the crass commercialization has defeated itself (or at least undermined; it always wins in the end). Despite the hoopla, the fact is that millions of people (of all ages and walks of life) took the American Idol "competition" to heart, adopting different contenders, voting repeatedly**, and -- you have to admit -- coming together and talking about something. Millions of people saw that old cliche, the American Dream, come true (albeit with all its dangers) for a sweet, humble girl from Texas -- and a broke cocktail waitress, no less.

And the winner, Kelly Clarkson, is -- just at this moment -- about the least commercialized pop star we have ever had in this country. She was CHOSEN by America. She's one of us, and, presumably, she's the one we want singing our national anthem. She's not singing the soon-t0-be-hit single from the show. It's not like it's Christina Aguilera (who may be singing elsewhere, for all I know).

So, while it's true that every television station that exists will be pumping out 9/11 remembrances and many of us (especially here) are having intense reactions to those memories, it's worth noting that.... well, that's what TV stations do. We're a televised culture and this is the most important thing that's happened in a generation. Singers will sing, bloggers will blog; thank heavens for options and the "power off" button. I won't be watching, but I'm glad it's Kelly Clarkson who's singing.

Next year, she may be a tool of the evil empire, but this week she's the bridge between the small town and the wide world. And there's nothing wrong with that.

Comment #2 :: link :: September 7, 2002 09:00 AM
Colin wrote:

*Our resident American Idol expert Chris (who follows these things) points out that Fox was approached by the organizers of the event, not the other way around. It's still business, of course, but it may not be quite as craven as it appears.

**A note on AI voting. When it came down to it, America -- voting as often as they wished, via a toll free phone call -- picked the "right" contestant. A more effective model, it turns out, than the Electoral College (at least when you introduce James Baker and a Bourgeoise Riot into the equation.)

Comment #3 :: link :: September 7, 2002 09:00 AM
Colin wrote:

(See? Pretty silly, right? I know. I'm not trying to say my "small things" strategy is good or noble or effective; it's just something that happens. But it turns out the small things are often connected to the big things. As in: isn't there some small comfort to be found in the fact that we can still feel silly and happy about a talent show? Even if you didn't, a lot of other people did; every little bit of normal life counts and you're entitled to yours where you find it. I doubt anyone is going to feel too little sadness this week, but I can guarantee that some people won't feel enough joy.)

Comment #4 :: link :: September 7, 2002 09:00 AM
wrote:

Well, I don't mean to dominate this whole thread (dominate, hell; I define it), but after all that drang (I'm cutting back on sturm), here's what Kelly Clarkson had to say about the 9/11 gig:

"'If anybody thinks I'm trying to market anything, well, that's awful,' she added. 'I am not going to do it.'"

Go Kelly! Go Kelly! Go! Go! Go Kelly!

Comment #5 :: link :: September 8, 2002 09:00 AM
Ennis wrote:

I'll be indoors, trying not to get hassled till the whole thing is over. I also have a deadline the next day, but the way that the public mood can turn ugly so quickly is something I'm not going to forget.

Comment #6 :: link :: September 9, 2002 09:00 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?




Enter the following security code to prove that you are human:





Note: HTML is allowed in your comment. Please be patient as posting can take up to a minute depending on traffic. If you're planning on spamming, don't bother; URLs in comments will not be indexed by any search engine.


















Ishbadiddle buttonTriptronix buttonMovable Type buttonMT Plugins buttonCreative Commons buttonCSS Tableless buttonEdit Pad buttonMax Design buttonLogin buttonEmail button

1m blogsageless buttonNYC Blogger buttonGeoURL buttonBlogdex buttonBlogShares buttonBlogstreet buttonEatonweb buttonTechnorati button

DonorsChoose buttonFlying Spaghetti MonsterGet Firefox!Stand up for your rightsWin With Blingo!

Ishbadiddle Full Posts Feed ButtonIshbadiddle Posts Excerpts Feed ButtonBloglines subscribe buttonIshbadiddle LiveJournal Feed Button