The Not-So-Great Pyramid

You may have read about the new food pyramid recently unveiled by the USDA. It's customized! It emphasizes exercise! (There's a little guy running up the side of it!) There are 12 of them!

The pyramid has come under fire by nutritionists who complain that it doesn't really encourage anyone to eat less of anything. But what bothers me about it is that it's not really a pyramid.

OK, so here's the old pyramid:

old food pyramid

The meaning of it is immediately clear: eat more of the stuff at the base, eat less of the stuff at the top. That's how a pyramid graphic should work. Here's the new one:

new food pyramid

By turning the sections on their side, there's no longer any relationship to the pyramid shape. Other than the guy running up the side of it. The amount of foods recommended still relate to the area covered, but the reader can't immediately grasp which foods to eat more of and which to eat less of. You could get the same information out of a stacked bar chart:

new pyramid in stacked bar graph format

Bad graphics. Someone get Tufte on the phone. Stat.



M E-L posted this on April 22, 2005 1:35 PM

This post is filed under: National News
Comments
Gazoo wrote:

for what it's worth, a great take on this in today's Slate, which asked four design teams to improve upon the USDA's waste of many years and many millions. See the link here.

http://slate.msn.com/id/2117642/

Comment #1 :: link :: April 28, 2005 2:41 PM
MEL wrote:

Thanks for those Paul ... they are much better. Now if only this crowd really believed in "Intelligent Design"...

Comment #2 :: link :: May 2, 2005 10:02 PM
Post a comment










Type the characters you see in the picture above.

















Ishbadiddle buttonTriptronix buttonMovable Type buttonCreative Commons buttonCSS Tableless buttonNotepad buttonMax Design buttonLogin buttonEmail button

ageless buttonNYC Blogger buttonGeoURL buttonBlogShares buttonTechnorati button

Flying Spaghetti MonsterGet Firefox!Stand up for your rights

Ishbadiddle Full Posts Feed ButtonIshbadiddle Posts Excerpts Feed ButtonBloglines subscribe buttonIshbadiddle LiveJournal Feed ButtonIshbadiddle Twitter Button