Back in bidness school, the conventional wisdom was that cause-related marketing (think Newman's Own) would not command a premium price, but ceteris paribus would influence a buyer to pick the do-gooder item.
A couple of b-school profs proved that wrong. They took a look at eBay purchases for similar items, that did and did not benefit charities: USNews.com: Money: The Price of Charity. They found an average of a 5% premium paid for items sold through Giving Works.
Hat tip to my colleague Amy W..